Happenings and goings on in the Archive and Study Centre: Events, researchers, discoveries, additions. For latest articles added to the Archive and Study Centre section of the website, click here.
The image immediately below: Researcher Paul Griffiths, PETT's final researcher; sitting at the first piece of furniture bought by the fledgling Archive a quarter of a century ago (salvage from the sea of financial renewal in Eastern Europe); bought for the use of the first researchers, and used by generations of researchers since.
December 9, 2018. As we enter into the final week of PETT's stewardship of the history of therapeutic communities, environments, and progressive/democratic/alternative education, the milestones become increasingly significant.
Our first researcher over a quarter of a century ago was the German student Axel Kuhn, studying A.S. Neill, the founder of Summerhill School (still thriving, and about to set up an archive of their own!). Our final researcher brings a convergence which approaches the exquisite.
Paul Griffiths' subject is John Layard, anthropologist and analytical psychologist, and devotee of Little Commonwealth founder and precocious psychoanalytically-informed therapist Homer Lane.
The Little Commonwealth inspired A.S. Neill; Homer Lane saved the psychological and emotional life of his client John Layard. In the swirl of people around Layard and the conversation between Archivist and Researcher are W.H. Auden, W.H.R. Rivers (of Craiglockhart Asylum, therapist of Siegfried Sassoon; subject of Pat Barker's "Regeneration" trilogy), Winnicott, Northfield, Finchden, David Wills, Withymead, Harry Wilmer, and at every turn in the hour-plus of pre-research discussion, another surprising connection with therapeutic community and people and places represented in the Archive.
Emerging from that rich flow of associations is another which - for an archive based in the ethnological tradition, and gathering and expressing the history and practice of planned environment therapy/therapeutic community (reference our GDPR statement) - is still another pleasing association: Layard's place in the history of this approach to people, societies, and cultures:
"Layard in Atchin [according to Wikipedia] and his contemporary Bronisław Malinowski in the Trobriand Islands of New Guinea were the first modern anthropologists to use what is today called participant observation methods in ethnographic research."
Malinowski! And not far away in the Archive Library and collections are Margaret Mead and Gregory Bateson, and of course Robert Rapaport of Henderson Hospital/"Community as Doctor" fame - social anthropogists whose lives and work influenced and interacted with the cultures of therapeutic communities. And did we mention anthropologist Neil Armstrong of Oxford University, whose work with and at the Archive on mental health provision in Oxford had its first public outing, in the Psychiatric Bulletin, earlier this year? Have a look at "What leads to innovation in mental health care? Reflections on clinical expertise in a bureaucratic age", and trace the lineage back.
Now very, very excited to see Paul Griffiths' book! Hurry, Paul!
Photograph above: The beauty of material culture: John Layard's own pocket knife, carried with him on his expedition to the New Hebrides (Vanuatu) in 1914, and - razor sharp - loaned there for circumcision rituals. Now accompanying the Researcher everywhwere.
A phone call out of the blue, a drive out into the Cotswolds, a phenomenal addition to the Archives.
Claire Baron's original notes for her powerful and influential research on the Paddington Day Hospital. Engaged and challenged by Helen Spandler's 2006 "Asylum to Action: Paddington Day Hospital, Therapeutic Communities and Beyond", Claire Baron's 1987 book "Asylum to Anarchy" is one of the few genuine classics in therapeutic community research and literature - grounded in participant observation as well as primary and secondary research, it remains seminal and provocative. And now, joining material from Claire's 2010 gift to the archives (accession 2010.098), the roots of that disturbing and disruptive research are gathered into the Archive for the use of future researchers.
They are supported in the Archive collections by Richard Crocket's archives (Richard Crocket was the psychiatrist appointed to take the helm of the Paddington Day Hospital in 1977-79 during the final Inquiry. There are also Craig Fees' recorded interviews with Dr. Crocket).
They are supported by other material as well, including a group of papers given by Jan Lees (accession 2000.007); material from Helen Spandler's research, including recorded interviews with principles and particpants; unpublished presentations at the 1979 Windsor Conference (in both Stuart Whiteley's Collection, and R.D Hinshelwood's Collection); and the minutes of the Association of Therapeutic Communities AGM in 1975, held at the Paddington Day Hospital (and found in both R.D. Hinshelwood's and Josephine Lomax-Simpson's Collections). An intrepid researcher is bound to find more, if only among the newsletters and ephemeral literature which are held in the Archive and Library.
Such as these: Among the research notes and materials which form part of accession 2018.048
Very exciting times to come for someone.
Gertie Shaw was born in December 1920, at home in Little Turner Street in the East End of London. Her brother was Harry Karnac, whose general bookstore in Gloucester Road, London, set up after the Second World War, gradually became the pre-eminent British bookstore for psychoanalytic and psychotherapeutic literature, and led to the foundation of Harry Karnac Books, the publishing house through which, as Brett Kahr wrote in his obituary of Harry, "Harry Karnac’s contribution as an educator of psychoanalytical students and as a disseminator of psychological culture remains unparalleled".
He was a close friend of Donald Winnicott, and later became a friend of the Planned Environment Therapy Trust Archive and Study Centre, for which he recorded interviews in 2003 and 2005, and to which he gave a number of books and publications related to Donald Winnicott and other leading psychoanalysts. He was a remarkable man from a remarkable family.
In 2015 we got an insight into that family in a recording of Mrs. Shaw by her son Simon, an excerpt from which - featuring her memories of the Battle of Cable Street - was shared on the PETT website (see and listen here).
Mrs. Shaw died on September 28th of this year (2018). Her son Simon Shaw, and daughter Marilyn John, recorded and wrote down her memories and comments, which have been lodged in the Archive (acc. 2018.034), along with the photograph above. Her following memories are shared with permission.
Memories – by Gertie Shaw (as recorded and transcribed by Simon Shaw)
Recorded 27th June 2014
I was born on 26th December 1920 at home in 33 Little Turner Street. I went to school, really a nursery when I was three years old. It was called Christian Street School. I went to proper school from nine in the morning until lunchtime. We used to go home at lunchtime.
School meals were only given to children who were really poverty stricken. In the afternoon they used to turn the tables upside down and slotted canvasses onto the legs to make little hammocks for the little children those between three and five.
Some children did the 11 plus, but we went to Fairclough Street it was a school for ball but the really clever children – it was a London County Council school.
We learnt reading and writing and a bit of history. We were frightened of the teachers, we had respect for them and we were in awe of them. Very few teachers lived in the area; they lived in areas we had never heard of outside London in the suburbs. All the teachers were women; I do not remember any male teachers.
There was always was a threat of the cane hanging over us. I remember once the teacher was screaming at us and her false teeth came and all of the children obviously laughed. For some reason she cottoned onto me and she came over and pushed my sleeve up and started whacking me on the arm. I went home with a bright red arm that I did not show to anybody and for some reason my sister Ann noticed it and she said what’s that, and she came up to school and tore the teacher off a strip and the teacher never hit anybody again.
I left school at 13. Unless they had a scholarship no one stayed on at school. My brother Harry went to Raynes, my mother managed to keep him at school until he was 16.
My mother managed to get me an apprenticeship with a hairdresser but I didn't like it, so I worked at a big store for a few years.
The apprenticeship took all my mothers savings, but it was really a rip off. Looking back at school it taught me to read and write but not much else. They did not make school more than a chore, but we never got any homework.
After school in the evening my brother and me played football or cricket in the street. The playgrounds were not in our area, our parents forbid us to go there and we were frightened. We were always set upon, there was a divide their side [non-Jewish] was St George’s, their side was nearer the docks.
My mother owned a clothing shop when we were very young. I did not have a father. Most women did shop work or worked in the clothing trade.
There was a tension in the area that came to a head in the 1930s. I think people got on with their lives; they had to work and feed their kids. Harry was very prominent in the Communist Party and he made us aware.
I remember on the day war broke out my mother go rid of all of Harry’s books. I think she was worried that the police would come around and think we were subversives.
I remember in 1936 we all went to Cable Street it was very crowded and noisy. There were a lot of police on horseback, which was an unusual sight. The Fascists were not able to get through because of the police, but mainly due to the barricades put up by the people, like mattresses and all sorts of rubbish. I think we were proud that we had stopped them from marching.
War followed quickly and we were worried about what would happen to the men who were called up.
There was a lot of bombing in the east end, but about a year into the war we went to live in Edgware. In the east end when we lived there we went to a billiard hall overnight to avoid the bombing, and a few times we went to Tottenham Court Road station to feel safe.
During the war schools still operated, but the day was shorter to allow them to get to the shelters. Ann and John were given a little house in the country but she only went there at the weekend.
I worked in the fire service, you had to join something. I did the general duties, mainly being on the phone to take emergency calls. We did a whole day and night on and a day and night off. We got very little pay for this, but we did get board and lodgings. I think women working like this was the dawn of emancipation.
We were sent to the suburbs when I was pregnant. I forget where, it was safer; there were no bombs in that area.
Judy and Marilyn left school and went into a trade. Judy went to Pitmans and learnt book keeping and short hand and some French.
Marilyn wanted to be a dressmaker and went to work in a factory. Magazines used to give away patterns and she designed the patterns, but she did not like it and left. She then went to work in the Post Office and was there for fifteen years, she did well and was very good at it.
Judy got married at nineteen and had Daniel soon afterwards.
Recorded January 1st, 2016
..[fades in].. doing the washing in Hessel Street, I remember when I was a teenager I never used to work on Saturday, the shop was never open, I don't know why. Even the big stores in the west end used to close on Saturday at 1pm. It was my job to do the washing for the whole family. I used to go down to the cellar and did all this bloody washing for the whole family – why didn't I object; I must have been there for hours. I was a real soft touch.
We used to dry it by hanging it up, we had no yard. Mice and rats inhabited it – I used to make aunty come down with me, as I was afraid.
We used to have a bath thing to do the washing in, a fire heated the water – I used to have schlapp it to the tap. It was a miserable time. I was washing for six – John was a baby, Ann and Yudi, Ann, mum and me.
The shop was only open in the morning on Sundays, but there were many people about they all went to church – there were some non-Jews living there. There were churches all over the place; the one in Commercial Road is still there.
I remember one Easter, which was our Passover we used to have a very busy time in the shop. John was a baby, so they stopped me off school for three weeks to help out. It was the one time I revolted, I said – I did not want to look after the baby he was smelly. I don't think I won. There was no school inspector, no one noticed – my schooling was so weak. The only time I enjoyed it was when I was leaving as I started to knowing. I can’t remember if I left school at thirteen or fourteen.
We used to come home in the lunch break, a lot of the ‘poor children’ (that's what we called them) stayed at school. My mum cooked a three course meal twice a day, aunty had to have a cooked meal in the evening – she would not eat a warmed up meal as she was a bloody nuisance.
Mum spent all day cooking in the most primitive conditions in the basement with the mice and rats. I am talking about the 1930s it was still very primitive.
Harry came home as well; he went to the same school, Christian Street – the girls on one side the boys on the other. It wasn't a happy childhood but we managed to survive. At least my mother did not put us in an orphanage as a lot of people said she should do as we had no father and there were two babies, Harry was only year older than me.
I think my mother went and looked at the Jewish orphanage, but she came back crying – she cried easily, like Ann. She had a lot to cry about, she had a sick husband [now talking about Ann her sister], he was a nice man, and he took in his mother in law. He had a shop selling curtains and linen, he did not make a living it was all hand to mouth. When he was well enough he went on a tram from the Commercial Road, I think it was the number 65 to Stratford to get stock for his shop.
The other morning I was thinking we used to play cricket in the street in the summer and football in the winter. Winters were bloody cold, we only had an open fire, and in the winter we burnt wood and if we could afford it coal.
When the shop closed we played in the street – whoever saw a car? Cars were not popular until after the war. God knows why Yudi was taking car lessons – we could never afford a car.
My mother would not let us cross the Commercial Road until we were ten or eleven; there were big trams on the Commercial Road.
It was strange we hardly had any money, when it came to rent time it was horrendous. But we were never short of food and we always had shoes to wear, because I remember kids coming to school with no shoes and you know we were always reasonably warm in the winter. I don't know how she managed that, she would not take anything she wasn't entitled to - she did not get the widows pension after the war; ‘its not mine, I should not be taking it’. They had a terrible time persuading her.
In the summer time I remember other children coming to school without shoes – the teachers were not very sympathetic people. Nearly every other person was out of work. It was hard times – hard times.
Jobs were hard for the teachers as well – they needed a job. We used to have Empire Day, one of the bigger girls used to dress up as Britannia. I cannot remember celebrating Christmas. We sang; long live our noble queen – no king. We celebrated fighting the Zulus – yonks ago.
There used to be an Irish sweep stake once a year, my mother had a part share with someone in the market and she won – her ticket was either ten shillings or a pound. She won a thousand pounds – an absolute fortune. Ann and Yudi rented a flat in Hackney and furnished it – a nice little flat on the ground floor. They, Ann and Yudi went there at the weekend – like going to the country. I don't know what I got, probably a bar of chocolate.
When they moved out, Ann got onto the landlord in Hessel Street and they built on another room. The flat in Hackney was empty during the week.
Yudi died the same week I got married, I think it was 1945 – no I got married before the end of the war – 1942.
Yudi died in his thirties. He had his own war fighting for breath. What Ann did during the war is a tough question; she shared a shop in the posh of the west end, opposite St James’s Park. Her friend made the dresses and Ann sold them.
Harry was in Canada for a long time during the war, I think he enjoyed Canada, he was single. I have no idea why he was in the Canadian Air Force.
If you were that sort of person a lot of money could be made during the war, because Ann hooked up with Jack, you have heard about him, this foreign person. Him and his brother went into the business of making handbags and Ann was head cook and bottle washer.
We found Jack when the war broke out, for some reason I lost my job and Bert wasn't called up, he was working in the workshop and Jack was an electrician in the workshop.
Bert brought him home and he took a shine to Ann. From then onwards they were a happy couple, to everyone’s disgust because he was a bastard. He never admitted where he came from – him and his brother were an evil pair. They did not care how they hurt people, I don't mean physically but mentally. He did not even treat her nicely.
He lived in a block of single roomed flats in the west end. But him and his brother were evil people lets not talk about them – he was horrible, him and Ann broke up, I never asked why. She liked him because he took her to posh places, expensive food, and clothes, places to live in the west end. He was a west bloke. He said he could speak French and Italian.
I went to the Young Communist League place in the square – the YC had a room. We went there in the evenings for lectures, we were taught to love Stalin and Lenin – in fact we were being brain washed weren’t we.
I went out collecting for Spain along the Commercial Road, I cannot remember how we collected it was a long time ago.
Recorded January 24th 2016
.. [fades in] …how many did they kill? Six million – terrible. So many children. My uncle with little children - four or five little ones. Ann went to Germany and Ukraine after the war and she came back and she was distraught. They lived in an agricultural part, but they were not farmers. My uncle lived with my grandmother but Ann could never find them, she went everywhere – she just could not find them. She went to all of the offices – the Red Cross – she was away for about three weeks.
The uncle was very young, the children were young, he was called David.
On Bert’s side, there were two sets of twins.
Ann went to look for them as soon as the war ended; they were putting out notices for those who were looking.
Recorded April 10th 2016
Harry and me both had measles we were about four or five years old and eggs came into the shop in great big crates and she made up a bed in the back of the shop. When I say a shop it was really just hole in the wall. She had no one to rely on, Ann was thirteen and she was at work. The shop sold eggs and cheese, no fridges; she just relied on the weather. She used to earn thrupence a week and she worked bloody hard.
There used to be a market in Hessel Street, it was underneath you and you had to go down a steep slope. In the market Yudi’s family sold household goods like curtains. The market was open everyday apart from Saturday. On Saturday people went to Victoria Park if the weather was nice or the library or park in Cable Street. Or in the winter we went to the pictures for three pence and that was the top seat, no it was six pence. There were three picture palaces, because the Troxy opened when I was a teenager, it was lush, beautiful – there were long queues waiting to get in when it opened. We probably went to see Astaire and Rogers.
There were two Jewish theatres one on the Commercial Road and one in Whitechapel. We used to get a lot of actors from America. We went to see Paul Robeson in the Albert Hall, I took mum she thoroughly enjoyed herself, and he had such a powerful voice. They demolished him – he had a sad end. He sang Ol’ Man River when we saw him. He was very popular, he had a powerful voice and left wing tendencies.
We got the 65 tram from the Commercial Road to Victoria Park. There used to be only a conductor.
At Gardiners Corner there was a big store selling mainly clothes. It was on the corner of Commercial Road and Whitechapel it was huge, at least it seemed huge to me at the time.
It was a very colourful place to live.
Blooms sold very nice sandwiches. They were always hot - salt beef on white bread, you used to eat the fat - very healthy! I think they were a hit during the war.
My mother was overprotective of us; she wouldn't let us cross the Commercial Road until we were teenagers. She was not keen on us going into the areas where there were ‘yocks’.
If Hitler had had his way he would have gone through all of us, because there were a lot of ‘frome’ ones. There was one very popular family selling wines and spirits on the Commercial Road on the corner of Cannon Street.
I cannot remember where I got married.
Nancy [Bert’s sister] used to live on Brick Lane. She was the second oldest of the girls, there was Nancy, Golda and Rosie.
April 10th 2016
The woman in the picture is the secretary of the Communist Party. She was a very clever woman, her name was Cissy Miller. She married Jack, I can’t remember his second name, and she became a suburban housewife. I met her once on the train coming up from Edgware and she never stopped talking, she was a very competent woman. Jack was also in the C.P.
They were not all poor people; the common dress in those days was all trousers and a jacket with a stiff collar and a waistcoat.
Phil Piratin the Member of Parliament was Ann’s neighbour; there were a lot of mutterings against him as he was the only communist M.P.
Nothing exciting ever happened in the east end, every now and then two neighbours would have a fight.
My mother did not let us go down Cable Street, she said; ‘you’re going to get killed’. In the C.P. we had a room where we had meetings and at the weekend dances.
I don't remember much about the day [the Battle of Cable Street, November 1936], we had to be careful about the horses treading on us. It was very warm.
My mother was not happy about us being in the C.P. Harry used to be in a book club, he had a book case full of Communist literature and she got rid of it when war was declared. I have never seen Harry so angry. He was furious. I think she sold his books.
She couldn't read. It’s our fault she couldn't read, but we didn't have the time and by the time she finished in the evening she was too tired. She was very keen to learn.
When we moved to Edgware she seemed to find her way about very quickly and she travelled on the underground by herself which was a formidable thing to do.
She travelled every shobas to Hessel Street to get a chicken. Then Bert had a little car and took her every week, Wednesday or Thursday. She had to be there to see them take all of the feathers off and take all the innards out to see it wasn't a sick chicken. She was very fussy about that sort of thing.
We used to sell household linens.
Anniversaries are always difficult to pinpoint: Like children, institutions and organisations have long formative periods before the gates open, and even then things are uncertain: The Mulberry Bush School is generally dated from its formal recognition by the State in 1948, but the earliest child's record gives the admission as 1947. And what about the Cassel Hospital? Founded and endowed by Ernst Cassel in 1919, it came alive when it admitted patients in 1921. After the Second World War it became one of the pioneering beacons of therapeutic community, with dynamic teams of nurses and psychiatrists - people such as Doreen Wedell and Eileen Skellern, Malcolm Pines and the Hospital's Director, Tom Main. With influential others.
These images are part of a group of eleven undated photographic slides which came to the Archive in 1999. Was the Cassel 80 then, or did it still have two years to go? Is the Cassel a hundred next year, or do we wait until 2021?
But these images and others, along with recordings, blueprints and diagrams, and published and unpublished documents from the Archive's holdings are likely to be part of the celebrations, whenever they're held. Relish and enjoy.
The note on the brown envelope in which the slides came
& Dr. Malcolm Pines"
Craig Fees writes (6 August 2018):
The photographs below were taken on the 29th of August, 2002, and document the archivist's office at the cusp of an interesting time. In September we would take over the Administration for the Association of Therapeutic Communities, shared between the Archive and the Trust office; earlier in the year the new conference and accommodation centre had opened, the new archive storage had become available, and we had lost assistant archivist Teresa Wilmshurst. In my June report for Trustees, I wrote
It has been a busy period, one of the busiest in many respects – looking at the number of oral history recordings, the number of researchers and visitors, the number of new accessions, for example – that we have had for some time. There has been a lot of structural work, such as physically cleaning new spaces, building shelves, moving and sorting materials, and doing the work necessary to enable the long-awaited air conditioning installation to go forward – drilling holes in walls, building a waterproof external cabinet. We have put together one and a half Joint Newsletters, moved the combined web-sites and email services to a new ISP, and responded to the emergency closure of Acacia Hall Therapeutic Community in Lincolnshire. We have also made our first small step into Europe (see 8, below).
And it has felt busier, in part because of problems with the computers, especially in the first part of the period – we’ve lost something over two weeks in aggregate dealing with them – and in part because it has been a period of reduced staffing – Teresa leaving in March, much of Maureen’s time taken up with VAT and end of year accounts, and her virtual loss for much of May and all of June (to date) as the conference and accommodation side has kicked in. Thank goodness for people’s sense of humour, and the invaluable contributions Maureen and Helen continue to make, and the support from John, and, of course, other trustees. The loss of Robert is keenly felt.
We didn't yet realise it, but in 2002 we were in the early stages of the long period of austerity whose consequences we are still living out, and to my eyes the photographs of the archive office show a period of innocent exuberance. There would not be a second archivist again until 2010 and the "Therapeutic Living With Other People's Children" project, and from August 2005 the lone archivist became part-time, sans budget.
For what are probably cyber-psychological reasons (computers have a mind of their own) these photographs surfaced today when they got hung up in transmission: Helen Moore is busily transferring the data from hundreds of old CDs and DVDS from our old CD/DVD-based digital storage system to the new, gigantically capacious RAID-configured digital storage system, where the files will become far more accessible (and hopefully safe from CD/DVD deterioration and decay). These photographs - out of many thousands - froze the system, and refused to be recognised or transferred. Computer problems over the years (see that June report!) have taught us many work-arounds, including the value of old and alternative hardware and software, and we ultimately retrieved the files. They clearly wanted to be seen. So here they are, fresh from August 29, 2002:
The West Wall
The North East Corner
The Eastern corner of the South wall
South meets West
And into the User's Room, and the Library Stacks
(with the lights on)
Page 1 of 23